PF1 Forum teammate wars vote: Austria
Posted: Mon Jul 01, 2019 8:18 am
The results from an entirely forgettable French grand prix are:
Mercedes
TMW race winner: Hamilton (100%)
Hamilton 6 - 2 Bottas
Hamilton 71% - 29% Bottas
Despite qualifying on the front row and finishing second, Valtteri Bottas receives all of zero votes in France, and it's an entirely fair result. He didn't really trouble Lewis at any point when it mattered, and while Lewis was cruising to another victory, Bottas was forced to defend his second place against Charles Leclerc on the last lap. It hands Bottas his third zero vote race of 2019, with Lewis extending his lead to 6-2 and padding the percentage side of things too.
Ferrari
TMW race winner: Leclerc (100%)
Vettel 6 - 2 Leclerc
Vettel 51% - 49% Leclerc
Another TMW vote where one driver received the full share and another where there shouldn't be any surprise at that. Charles Leclerc was clearly the faster of the two Ferrari drivers. Vettel's Q3 was perhaps compromised by a transmission issue but he also seemed to suggest his second run simply wasn't good enough, and left him with a recovery job on Sunday, which he did the bare minimum of by reaching P5. Meanwhile his teammate was, as previously mentioned, hounding down the second of the two Mercedes on the last lap. It's a result that ends a run of five successive TMW victories for Seb Vettel, as well as inflicting his first zero vote TMW result of the season.
Red Bull
TMW race winner: Verstappen (100%)
Verstappen 8 - 0 Gasly
Verstappen 97% - 3% Gasly
Thanks to results elsewhere, Pierre Gasly is now dead last in the TMW votes. Another 0 vote race (his fifth of the year, equaling Giovinazzi as the 'leader' in that statistic) means that he is one of two drivers yet to claim a TMW win, and now the only driver averaging less than a single vote per race. And as much as I do usually try to avoid saying anything about the race we're all voting on so as not to influence people's opinions in any way, I think I would be safe to say that things are probably not going to look any better for him after yesterday!
Renault
TMW race winner: Ricciardo (65%)
Ricciardo 6 - 2 Hulkenberg
Ricciardo 53% - 47% Hulkenberg
Daniel Ricciardo makes it six TMW wins in a row, but once again it's a close run thing with arguments for both drivers. Daniel qualified ahead and was ahead for the majority of the race, which seems to be what has earned him the larger share of the votes. However, his attempts to get ahead of Lando Norris at the end of the race ultimately dropped him behind Nico Hulkenberg and out of the points, and that is clearly something that has counted against him with some of the voters. Either way the percentage vote between the pair is still pretty close, even if the 6-2 score for the season might suggest otherwise.
Haas
TMW race winner: Magnussen (69%)
Magnussen 6 - 2 Grosjean
Magnussen 67% - 33% Grosjean
Was that Haas' worst race in F1 yet? Only kept off the bottom of the order by virtue of Williams being, well, the 2019 Williams. Magnussen was deemed to have had the slightly less awful weekend and becomes another driver to enjoy a 6-2 TMW advantage.
McLaren
TMW race winner: Sainz (65%)
Sainz 6 - 2 Norris
Sainz 49% - 51% Norris
Again, not a great deal to choose between the competitive McLaren pair, but once more it's Carlos Sainz who edges ahead. Norris had the better Saturday and impressively leads the head-to-head 5-3, but for the second race in a row was the McLaren driver to experience reliability issues. For a while it looked like a second successive DNF was inevitable but the car ultimately held together long enough for him to finish P10 on the road, promoted to P9 courtesy of Daniel Ricciardo's penalties. However, Carlos Sainz had already scampered away to claim the best-of-the-rest honours.
Racing Point
TMW race winner: Perez (88%)
Perez 6 - 2 Stroll
Perez 62% - 38% Stroll
6-2 seems to be an incredibly popular TMW score. Another enjoying that advantage is Sergio Perez, who rebounded from a poor showing in Canada to outpace his young teammate. Qualifying was once more particularly poor for Lance, who didn't get out of Q1 despite his teammate managing to bang in a top-10 lap shortly before Stroll crossed the line. The race was closer as Lance again tried to a long first stint but, on this occasion, failed to make it work and ended up finishing behind his teammate.
Alfa-Romeo
TMW race winner: Raikkonen (98%)
Raikkonen 7 - 1 Giovinazzi
Raikkonen 89% - 11% Giovinazzi
After breaking his TMW duck in Canada it was back to reality for Giovinazzi in France. Perhaps the percentage of votes scored by Kimi was a little harsh given Gio got his car into Q3, something his teammate failed to do, and was ultimately on the wrong strategy for the race as a result. But then again Kimi ended up finishing 7th while Giovinazzi simply went backwards in the race, so maybe it isn't so harsh!
Toro Rosso
TMW race winner: Kvyat (75%)
Albon 3 - 5 Kvyat
Albon 35% - 65% Kvyat
Not a memorable race for the Toro Rosso pair, but Daniil Kvyat once again gets the TMW spoils. Alex Albon did outqualify him, although how much that was down to Toro Rosso knowing Kvyat had many penalties and didn't bother trying too hard is another question. In the race the two gradually converged before Kvyat got past Albon on track, which was probably the telling moment for a lot of voters.
Williams
TMW race winner: Russell (71%)
Russell 8 - 0 Kubica
Russell 91% - 9% Kubica
Another race, another George Russell win. Robert Kubica did start ahead of him for the first time this year, albeit only because of penalties, and did finish ahead of him as well. However, it looks like there is a degree of sympathy from voters for the way Russell's first attempt at passing Kubica saw him pushed off the track, damaging his front wing and necessitating an extra pit stop. The fact that he then made the same move stick some laps later can't have hurt, either. It was at least a better split of the votes for Kubica, jumping his percentage for the year up to 9% and lifting him clear of Pierre Gasly in that respect.
Mercedes
TMW race winner: Hamilton (100%)
Hamilton 6 - 2 Bottas
Hamilton 71% - 29% Bottas
Despite qualifying on the front row and finishing second, Valtteri Bottas receives all of zero votes in France, and it's an entirely fair result. He didn't really trouble Lewis at any point when it mattered, and while Lewis was cruising to another victory, Bottas was forced to defend his second place against Charles Leclerc on the last lap. It hands Bottas his third zero vote race of 2019, with Lewis extending his lead to 6-2 and padding the percentage side of things too.
Ferrari
TMW race winner: Leclerc (100%)
Vettel 6 - 2 Leclerc
Vettel 51% - 49% Leclerc
Another TMW vote where one driver received the full share and another where there shouldn't be any surprise at that. Charles Leclerc was clearly the faster of the two Ferrari drivers. Vettel's Q3 was perhaps compromised by a transmission issue but he also seemed to suggest his second run simply wasn't good enough, and left him with a recovery job on Sunday, which he did the bare minimum of by reaching P5. Meanwhile his teammate was, as previously mentioned, hounding down the second of the two Mercedes on the last lap. It's a result that ends a run of five successive TMW victories for Seb Vettel, as well as inflicting his first zero vote TMW result of the season.
Red Bull
TMW race winner: Verstappen (100%)
Verstappen 8 - 0 Gasly
Verstappen 97% - 3% Gasly
Thanks to results elsewhere, Pierre Gasly is now dead last in the TMW votes. Another 0 vote race (his fifth of the year, equaling Giovinazzi as the 'leader' in that statistic) means that he is one of two drivers yet to claim a TMW win, and now the only driver averaging less than a single vote per race. And as much as I do usually try to avoid saying anything about the race we're all voting on so as not to influence people's opinions in any way, I think I would be safe to say that things are probably not going to look any better for him after yesterday!
Renault
TMW race winner: Ricciardo (65%)
Ricciardo 6 - 2 Hulkenberg
Ricciardo 53% - 47% Hulkenberg
Daniel Ricciardo makes it six TMW wins in a row, but once again it's a close run thing with arguments for both drivers. Daniel qualified ahead and was ahead for the majority of the race, which seems to be what has earned him the larger share of the votes. However, his attempts to get ahead of Lando Norris at the end of the race ultimately dropped him behind Nico Hulkenberg and out of the points, and that is clearly something that has counted against him with some of the voters. Either way the percentage vote between the pair is still pretty close, even if the 6-2 score for the season might suggest otherwise.
Haas
TMW race winner: Magnussen (69%)
Magnussen 6 - 2 Grosjean
Magnussen 67% - 33% Grosjean
Was that Haas' worst race in F1 yet? Only kept off the bottom of the order by virtue of Williams being, well, the 2019 Williams. Magnussen was deemed to have had the slightly less awful weekend and becomes another driver to enjoy a 6-2 TMW advantage.
McLaren
TMW race winner: Sainz (65%)
Sainz 6 - 2 Norris
Sainz 49% - 51% Norris
Again, not a great deal to choose between the competitive McLaren pair, but once more it's Carlos Sainz who edges ahead. Norris had the better Saturday and impressively leads the head-to-head 5-3, but for the second race in a row was the McLaren driver to experience reliability issues. For a while it looked like a second successive DNF was inevitable but the car ultimately held together long enough for him to finish P10 on the road, promoted to P9 courtesy of Daniel Ricciardo's penalties. However, Carlos Sainz had already scampered away to claim the best-of-the-rest honours.
Racing Point
TMW race winner: Perez (88%)
Perez 6 - 2 Stroll
Perez 62% - 38% Stroll
6-2 seems to be an incredibly popular TMW score. Another enjoying that advantage is Sergio Perez, who rebounded from a poor showing in Canada to outpace his young teammate. Qualifying was once more particularly poor for Lance, who didn't get out of Q1 despite his teammate managing to bang in a top-10 lap shortly before Stroll crossed the line. The race was closer as Lance again tried to a long first stint but, on this occasion, failed to make it work and ended up finishing behind his teammate.
Alfa-Romeo
TMW race winner: Raikkonen (98%)
Raikkonen 7 - 1 Giovinazzi
Raikkonen 89% - 11% Giovinazzi
After breaking his TMW duck in Canada it was back to reality for Giovinazzi in France. Perhaps the percentage of votes scored by Kimi was a little harsh given Gio got his car into Q3, something his teammate failed to do, and was ultimately on the wrong strategy for the race as a result. But then again Kimi ended up finishing 7th while Giovinazzi simply went backwards in the race, so maybe it isn't so harsh!
Toro Rosso
TMW race winner: Kvyat (75%)
Albon 3 - 5 Kvyat
Albon 35% - 65% Kvyat
Not a memorable race for the Toro Rosso pair, but Daniil Kvyat once again gets the TMW spoils. Alex Albon did outqualify him, although how much that was down to Toro Rosso knowing Kvyat had many penalties and didn't bother trying too hard is another question. In the race the two gradually converged before Kvyat got past Albon on track, which was probably the telling moment for a lot of voters.
Williams
TMW race winner: Russell (71%)
Russell 8 - 0 Kubica
Russell 91% - 9% Kubica
Another race, another George Russell win. Robert Kubica did start ahead of him for the first time this year, albeit only because of penalties, and did finish ahead of him as well. However, it looks like there is a degree of sympathy from voters for the way Russell's first attempt at passing Kubica saw him pushed off the track, damaging his front wing and necessitating an extra pit stop. The fact that he then made the same move stick some laps later can't have hurt, either. It was at least a better split of the votes for Kubica, jumping his percentage for the year up to 9% and lifting him clear of Pierre Gasly in that respect.